You can only pick one!

[Yvi]

bonus npc: the gal at the joja mart cash register :( i'd remove her just to put her out of her misery so she doesn't have to exist without recognition anymore

Same! I feel so bad for her, she looks so miserable. I hope that she gets a better job somewhere that makes her happy.

 

[RoseNoire]

Honestly, I don't think some people are thinking through their choices. If you remove the NPC, you remove from the game the things that NPC can provide you.

Mr Qi? Well, good bye to all those end-game perks on Ginger Island.

Similar things happen with most of the other people mentioned. Be careful what you wish for, people. Your wish might be provided via monkey-paw.

I'd still ask for Mr Qi to be gone. He's ruining the cosy vibes so much with his antics and clearly being an antagonist hiding in plain sight that we can't get rid of. I'd sacrifice the perks with no hesitation. The addition of mystery boxes isn't even good. Mr Qi actively littering the valley for us to find random stuff and boxes like we're some kind of hamster needing enrichment. The game has become rather bleak with 1.6.

(And outside of Qi, I'm not a fan of reward tickets either for the same reason as mystery boxes. We were already getting a kind reward from the villagers and we felt less forced to "do it for the reward" back then where there was not a bigger reward. Lewis, your idea backfired so bad)

The valley would be better without Qi, period.

 

[CheesePoopStardew]

Has to be Penny - Why ? I hate teachers and if they all disappeared tomorrow I would not shed a tear, they all deserve to rot in hell.

actually, the teachers don't have to teach you, they are doing it because a lot of them actually care. all they're doing is doing their job. And you can't say it doesn't help you get a job, so i'm sorry, but I don't agree with you.

 

[PebbleStardew]

Shane. Luv him and I hate LEWIS. and MORRIS

 

[CheesePoopStardew]

I guess if I had to choose, Linus? Correct if wrong, but I don't think he develops much?

I don't think I would since he gives me the wild bait recipe

 

[CheesePoopStardew]

Shane. Luv him

i'm not removing him because of all the blue chickens

 

[CheesePoopStardew]

I would surely remove Morris, that Joja guy!!!

 

[PebbleStardew]

no I misread srry. I hate lewis crane guy and morris or Vincent or jas

 

[Sockpuppet]

actually, the teachers don't have to teach you, they are doing it because a lot of them actually care. all they're doing is doing their job. And you can't say it doesn't help you get a job, so i'm sorry, but I don't agree with you.

Have you ever been tortured and attacked, day after day by a teacher as a young 8 year old who had no idea what was happening and thought it was normal behavior until as a twelve year old then realized after changing schools that it was not normal for a teacher to attack you every day. No, teachers do not have to teach students and they do not have to torture, insult and attack little kids but they do. Then when I started high school I was tough enough to fight back and never put up with any teachers bull ****, I gave them so much grief I was banned from 4 classes for being too disruptive and habitual fighting, I trashed classrooms and had the Police attend the school because of my behavior. Finally I was expelled for throwing a typewriter at a teacher. Yeah that teacher taught me well an A+ in how to be just as violent as he was.

 

[Eminy]

Abigail

 

[Maxxi]

If you could pick one character/NPC to be removed from the game, who would you chose and why?

I would chose Gunther, because I find it ridiculous that we can't even befriend him.
View attachment 29181

I would most likely choose to take Gunther out of the game too, i do love the rewards system in the museum, but i do wish you could do more with him

 

[pealee]

Crane guy obviously

 

[stardew_luv]

Has to be Penny - Why ? I hate teachers and if they all disappeared tomorrow I would not shed a tear, they all deserve to rot in hell.

Woah. That’s a pretty intense response. If you learned anything in life from anyone they are a pseudo teacher. And you want them in hell why? Would you prefer a total memory erase of all things you ever learned and have zero intelligence whatsoever to the point you wouldn’t even be able to write what you just did? THAT would be your REAL life if all teachers disappeared and were rotting in hell. This message has been brought to you by a teacher btw. You can not like Penny, but to disrespect the work done freely with very little thanks or compensation in return by countless individuals out there and a generous handful here is uncalled for. Not all teachers are good but a great many have helped you form who you are or even your ability to express who you are in words to some degree. It’s a noble and selfless profession often administered to thankless students such as yourself for completely free on your behalf. If you still think so lowly of us then you should at least think of the fact that you couldn’t even form and write that thought if it weren’t for a teacher somewhere at some point in your life giving you that ability. You’re welcome!

 

[NextXander]

@pealee @Lenora Rose Hey, your posts were removed for going way off-topic from the thread's topic (which villagers you'd remove). @Sockpuppet That also applies to your posts, but in addition, the subject matter wasn't appropriate for these forums. Avoid discussion of abuse and other heavy topics. As a general reminder for everyone, please try to stick to game discussion in this forum section.