Stardew Valley Cookbook Achievement Pictures

Pina Colada.jpg


"If you like Pina Coladas, and gettin caught in the rain. If you're not into yoga, if you have half a brain..."

That song has been in my head all night while my mom and I made this.

A mixture of coconut cream, coconut water, sugar, lime juice, pineapples, and either dark rum, more coconut water, pineapple juice, or whatever tropical fruit juice you like. (We used something called "Tropical Blend" so it's pretty tangy.)

We also made sure to find any cups in the shape of hollowed out coconuts we could to maintain the spirit of the game's recipe. We also have enough coconut cream leftover that we'll have plenty more to go over the weekend. Good thing too due to a heat wave and drought we're facing right now.
 

billkf

Greenhorn
View attachment 35570View attachment 35571View attachment 35572View attachment 35573View attachment 35574View attachment 35575

Stardew Valley Chocolate Cake, favored by Abigail, Evelyn, and Jodi. (The latter of whom has an interesting blurb in the book about maybe convincing Kent, Sam, and Vincent to try their hand at making one for one of her birthdays...)

This one, I have A LOT to say about. We have plans to bake this around Valentine's Day and figured we could use a "dry run" now to see if we could learn anything important before then. Turns out, more than we thought.

First challenge: finding the right ingredients and tools. We had to look for bittersweet chocolate, a kind we don't normally use for anything. We had to get a posted cake slicer since a bread knife would not only be too short and unwieldy, but the bottom layers were huge. We also had to get new cake pans of varying sizes: 10, 8 and 5 inches respectively. Then we needed to buy an icing spreader.

Another challenge: 'finely' chopping the bittersweet chocolate that would eventually go into the frosting, which in this case is a chocolate 'ganache'. After chopping the chocolate with knives and cutting boards, we decided to use our food processor, which helped but still took a while due to the nature of chocolate. And this was just for early prep work.

Next, over yesterday, we made the cakes themselves. The batter consisted of a mixture of cocoa powder, butter, and 'strong' coffee, and other dry powdered ingredients like flour, baking powder, etc. Now keep in mind, this is a 3-tiered cake, which means A LOT OF BATTER! With the bowls we had, the mixture, needing to be all done together at once, almost overflowed our largest bowl, but we barely avoided that. Next time, we will use a bowl with over twice the capacity that we just got afterwards.

Next challenge: baking the 3 cakes in the different pans. After dusting and greasing the pans and laying some parchment paper, we were luckily able to fit them in the oven all at once. But we had to use a lot of timing because different-sized cakes require different cooking durations. Plus, even after taking them out of the oven, they each had to be left on a wire rack for a while, inverted after another while and removed from the pans. That required different timings, too.

And that was just day 1. Today, we did the ganache frosting and assembled the full cake. That required warming some heavy cream and using it to melt the chocolate we cut previously. Then it had to sit for an hour, then chill in the fridge, all while being mixed at certain times until it reached a very thick consistency. Once the time came to trim the cakes and assemble them, we also had to cut the cakes in half for a total of 6 layers.

Despite the recipe calling for a certain amount of ganache, it was actually just barely enough for each layer, and some of the top layers got less than the book thought we could use. Turns out, ganache is so thick and sticky it's hard to use it all. And we had to sprinkle semi-sweet chocolate chips every other layer. We also had some spare chocolate chips from the holidays to decorate the outside with.

Finally, the cake has a cute little maraschino cherry on top. I decided that I'd take pictures with and without the stem. Final height: 8.5 inches!

Now for the million-dollar question: will it fit under the glass dome? LMAO
wow, great!
 
Last edited:
Shrimp Cocktail Attempt 1.jpg
Shrimp Cocktail Attempt 2.jpg


Shrimp Cocktail.

This one was the only other seafood recipe in the book after the Chowder that my mom could stomach, so we opted for it. This platter requires extra-jumbo shrimp, de-shelled and de-veined, and a cocktail sauce that's quite different from the typical store-bought variety. It includes grape tomatoes, shallots, garlic, extra-virgin olive oil, honey, ground cloves, allspice, baked in the oven, then blended with lemon juice and grated horseradish root. Take away the horseradish, and it could be mistaken for marinara.

This one took a second attempt, because the first time, I made a pretty stupid mistake: I misread the digital scale we used to measure the tomatoes and, in some uncharacteristic brain-lag on my part, I didn't notice that the scale had multiple unit options aside from metric ounces and accidentally used 16 grams of tomatoes instead of 16 ounces to make a full pound. 16 grams is only a small handful, so with fewer tomatoes absorbing the heat during the baking process, it came out slightly blackened.

The end result of attempt number 1 was only enough sauce for 1 glass, which we were lucky to have on hand to mark the occasion.

Attempt number 2 was better, but somehow the allspice got away from me when I sprinkled it out. I only needed a pinch and got about a tablespoon or two of it. The sauce was stronger and heavier for it, but better than the first time. I don't really know why this has been happening. Maybe I wasn't in a good headspace during these times, but it was worth it.

Also, next time we will be sure to get fresh shrimp from a local fish shop like we did for the clam chowder. In this case, we were able to get frozen shrimp, but we had to defrost them and remove the shells. Then we had to roast the shrimp for a bit. Now we fully understand why some shrimp looks sickly gray and other shrimp looks pink.

A lot of lessons learned during this dish, but we'll try again someday.
 
Finally got to the Pink Cake.

This is a buttermilk cake with a homemade jam with strawberry and watermelon, and a strawberry cream cheese and butter frosting, topped with more strawberries.

The jam had to stew and chill for a bit, then we had to bake the cake layers themselves, let them chill, then make and apply the frosting. The initial recipe calls for freeze-dried strawberries ground into the frosting, and some reserved for the top, but we also put fresh strawberries on top of those. Reason: as we know from the in-game description, the top strawberries are supposed to be in the shape of
♥️
and freeze-dried strawberries are too brittle to cut and shape.

In the end, we ended up with a cake that was really sweet, rich in flavor, particularly in the jam and frosting, and honestly, a cake we liked better than the Chocolate Cake we did last winter. Even though it's smaller than the last cake, it's still too big to fit under any of our cake domes or any we could find online. Luckily, it could just barely fit in the fridge.

7 hours of prepping, checking ingredients, baking, and decorating, all worth it.

More pictures in the next post.

top front freeze dried.jpg
front view freeze dried.jpg
more frontal freeze dried.jpg
leftish freeze dried.jpg
full left freeze dried.jpg
rightish freeze dried.jpg
full right freeze dried.jpg
back view freeze dried.jpg
 
Looks awesome, would definitely want to try this one!
Also kind of funny how strawberries are in the game, but not in the recipe for the cake, there's only a melon. I guess not an uncommon mismatch.
True. The strawberries are the more prominent flavor in this recipe being in the frosting and top decorations, but I think the watermelon ties it all together even though it's just in the jam.
 

Dreyski

Farmer
Now that's impressive!

Two questions:
Did the icing colour actually come from the strawberries? Freeze dried strawberries aren't easy to come by in the UK, so I might have to find a substitute.
How was the consistency and quantity of the icing? (from weight, the amount comes to around 2.5 pounds!)
 
Now that's impressive!

Two questions:
Did the icing colour actually come from the strawberries? Freeze dried strawberries aren't easy to come by in the UK, so I might have to find a substitute.
How was the consistency and quantity of the icing? (from weight, the amount comes to around 2.5 pounds!)
1. Yes, the color did come from just the freeze-dried strawberries ground into fine powder and mixed into it. I found the freeze dried strawberries at Harris Teeter, so I hope you find them or find a good online vendor that ships them.
2. The consistency was pretty thick but maybe not quite clotted so it could be squeezed out of a traditional piping bag and star top, and the quantity of the icing was such that we had plenty to spare; like almost twice as much made as we used. But we didn't go crazy on decorating beyond what you see in the pictures, so I think that's what all that extra icing is for. it takes 1 and 1/8 ounces of freeze-dried strawberries to make the listed amount of icing, some of which was to be reserved for the 8 pieces on top. The rest is cream cheese and butter.
 

Gardening Spirit

Guest
Looks amazing! I've got the SDV cookbook as well and it always looked like a challenging recipe and you've done it beautifully :)
 
Looks amazing! I've got the SDV cookbook as well and it always looked like a challenging recipe and you've done it beautifully :)
Thanks.

Honestly, there are varying difficulty and time-consumption levels for every recipe that I think should be clearly printed in a hypothetical future version of this book.

Some are incredibly quick and easy and some are best done over a period of several hours or even a whole day or two, like the Chocolate Cake. That one took a few days to do.

The Pink Cake took a combined 7 hours to make and we weren't really hustling.
 

juminocass

Greenhorn
I have been having so much fun crusing through the Stardew Valley Cookbook. I've made 9/52 recipes so far! I came across this thread a few months ago when I started this journey and figured I'd share what I've made so far 🙂

Fish Tacos - the spices on these weren't my favourite and the tuna was SO expensive. Likely won't come back to this one again.
1000026807.jpg


Blueberry Tart - made peak blueberry season with farm fresh berries. No notes. Would 1000% make again. Quite laborious and time consuming. Many steps!
1000026543.jpg


Chocolate Chip Cookies - amazingly perfect chewy cookies. Will make again! Very time consuming as the dough needs to rest/chill several times through the process. Simple otherwise.
1000026804.jpg


Fruit salad - too sweet for my taste but was fun to use real vanilla bean for the first time. Added great flavour.
1000027337.jpg


Ginger ale - I LOVE sodas and this syrup was perfect. I did cut the sweet in half but loved the fresh ginger flavour. Will definitely make again.
1000027347.jpg


Crab cakes - DELICIOUS. Peach salsa at the height of peach season was 11/10. Will definitely come back to these.
1000027361.jpg


Farmers Lunch - I have never used this whipping method for making omelettes and the result was great! End result was an incredibly fluffy omelette! The parsnips and greens had a perfect maple flavour from the syrup. Will make the omelette again for sure.
1000028640.jpg


Pina Coladas - these were so fun to do with a big group but I can't say I loved the flavour. The coconut shells are sooo much work to prep. Fun to make overall but wouldn't go through the effort again.
1000027630.jpg


Complete Breakfast - okay YUM. The hash browns were perfect. Will make again. Fruit compote used cranberries instead of rhubarb as rhubarb isn't available where I am rn. The pancakes were a little heavy so might play with the recipe next time. This is a lengthy process with many steps so I doubt I'll make this full breakfast again, but I will be making individual items separate.
1000028664.jpg


I'll share more as I work my way through the book. I am aiming for completion of the entire book with the exception of the seafoam pudding 🤮

Undecided what I'll dive into next but looking forward to starting some of the Fall recipes!
 
I have been having so much fun crusing through the Stardew Valley Cookbook. I've made 9/52 recipes so far! I came across this thread a few months ago when I started this journey and figured I'd share what I've made so far 🙂

Fish Tacos - the spices on these weren't my favourite and the tuna was SO expensive. Likely won't come back to this one again.
View attachment 41002

Blueberry Tart - made peak blueberry season with farm fresh berries. No notes. Would 1000% make again. Quite laborious and time consuming. Many steps!
View attachment 41003

Chocolate Chip Cookies - amazingly perfect chewy cookies. Will make again! Very time consuming as the dough needs to rest/chill several times through the process. Simple otherwise.
View attachment 41005

Fruit salad - too sweet for my taste but was fun to use real vanilla bean for the first time. Added great flavour.
View attachment 41006

Ginger ale - I LOVE sodas and this syrup was perfect. I did cut the sweet in half but loved the fresh ginger flavour. Will definitely make again.
View attachment 41007

Crab cakes - DELICIOUS. Peach salsa at the height of peach season was 11/10. Will definitely come back to these.
View attachment 41008

Farmers Lunch - I have never used this whipping method for making omelettes and the result was great! End result was an incredibly fluffy omelette! The parsnips and greens had a perfect maple flavour from the syrup. Will make the omelette again for sure.
View attachment 41009

Pina Coladas - these were so fun to do with a big group but I can't say I loved the flavour. The coconut shells are sooo much work to prep. Fun to make overall but wouldn't go through the effort again.
View attachment 41010

Complete Breakfast - okay YUM. The hash browns were perfect. Will make again. Fruit compote used cranberries instead of rhubarb as rhubarb isn't available where I am rn. The pancakes were a little heavy so might play with the recipe next time. This is a lengthy process with many steps so I doubt I'll make this full breakfast again, but I will be making individual items separate.
View attachment 41011

I'll share more as I work my way through the book. I am aiming for completion of the entire book with the exception of the seafoam pudding 🤮

Undecided what I'll dive into next but looking forward to starting some of the Fall recipes!
Oh! My! Gosh! These look amazing! I want to grab everything out of these pictures and scarf them all down! You did great!

I'm jealous that you got the chance to make several seafood dishes that no one in my circle either has time for or even likes. Most are too picky with seafood.

And you used real vanilla bean for the fruit salad? I haven't tried that yet, but I may get a chance this weekend if everything else is still available.

And that blueberry tart... honestly, you could save yourself a lot of time and trouble if you just make the curd. That's easily the best part, yes?

No rhubarb? Any local Harris Teeter in your area? They get lucky sometimes with certain ingredients.

I don't blame you for the seafoam pudding. My dad loves everything seafood, but even he balked when I showed him the part where it uses squid ink as an ingredient.

I seem to recall hearing that separating the whites of the eggs and whipping them like that for the farmer's lunch is a technique used in many centuries past when omlettes had much more notoriety and were seen as an art form. Maybe even as far back as the medieval days. I don't know of any restaurants these days who take the time and build the skill to do that, but I'd love it if they did.

You hollowed out real coconuts? How did you do that? I tried to find a way when I did that recipe, but had no luck finding any coconuts or learning the technique.

When you get to the fall recipes, I strongly suggest you try out the pumpkin pie and soup. And the survival burger has a great sauce recipe that works on any burger.
 

juminocass

Greenhorn
Oh! My! Gosh! These look amazing! I want to grab everything out of these pictures and scarf them all down! You did great!

I'm jealous that you got the chance to make several seafood dishes that no one in my circle either has time for or even likes. Most are too picky with seafood.

And you used real vanilla bean for the fruit salad? I haven't tried that yet, but I may get a chance this weekend if everything else is still available.

And that blueberry tart... honestly, you could save yourself a lot of time and trouble if you just make the curd. That's easily the best part, yes?

No rhubarb? Any local Harris Teeter in your area? They get lucky sometimes with certain ingredients.

I don't blame you for the seafoam pudding. My dad loves everything seafood, but even he balked when I showed him the part where it uses squid ink as an ingredient.

I seem to recall hearing that separating the whites of the eggs and whipping them like that for the farmer's lunch is a technique used in many centuries past when omlettes had much more notoriety and were seen as an art form. Maybe even as far back as the medieval days. I don't know of any restaurants these days who take the time and build the skill to do that, but I'd love it if they did.

You hollowed out real coconuts? How did you do that? I tried to find a way when I did that recipe, but had no luck finding any coconuts or learning the technique.

When you get to the fall recipes, I strongly suggest you try out the pumpkin pie and soup. And the survival burger has a great sauce recipe that works on any burger.
Thanks! It's been so much fun!

Yes, I used real vanilla bean! Found it at a local bulk store. It really adds to the flavour. I had to Google what they looked like cause I didn't even know what I was looking for at the store haha.

Rhubarb is super out of season here! I'm in southern Canada. I didn't look incredibly hard but my main grocery store didn't even have it frozen. I'll have to wait for next Spring to do the pie!

Super interesting about the omelettes - it was such a fun technique I will definitely use again.

Sooo for the coconuts, I actually sent a friend on a grand adventure to prep the shells. It was quite an ordeal and I believe they had to use a drill and a hand or power saw 😅 to get them open. She suffered many hand wounds from the outside of the shells! I was able to find them at my local grocery store though. If you have a grocery store that promotes that they have more "international ingredients" - you may have luck! My store has them available most of the time in the produce section. Many Asian grocers stock them locally as well.

I'll take your suggestions for fall recipes and prioritize those - they all caught my eye (I love anything pumpkin)

How many recipes do you have left before you've completed the book? Are you aiming to make them all?
 
Thanks! It's been so much fun!

Yes, I used real vanilla bean! Found it at a local bulk store. It really adds to the flavour. I had to Google what they looked like cause I didn't even know what I was looking for at the store haha.

Rhubarb is super out of season here! I'm in southern Canada. I didn't look incredibly hard but my main grocery store didn't even have it frozen. I'll have to wait for next Spring to do the pie!

Super interesting about the omelettes - it was such a fun technique I will definitely use again.

Sooo for the coconuts, I actually sent a friend on a grand adventure to prep the shells. It was quite an ordeal and I believe they had to use a drill and a hand or power saw 😅 to get them open. She suffered many hand wounds from the outside of the shells! I was able to find them at my local grocery store though. If you have a grocery store that promotes that they have more "international ingredients" - you may have luck! My store has them available most of the time in the produce section. Many Asian grocers stock them locally as well.

I'll take your suggestions for fall recipes and prioritize those - they all caught my eye (I love anything pumpkin)

How many recipes do you have left before you've completed the book? Are you aiming to make them all?
20260820_231945.jpg
20260820_231952.jpg


This is my progress so far, along with a few notes I made for myself.

I would love to make all of these, but several are subject to both the palettes of the people in my life and ingredient availability.

For example, the radish salad requires "French breakfast radishes" which I'd have to grow myself, and even though I've done the roots platter, I had to radically replace one ingredient which felt wrong: Tokyo turnips/hakurei. I swapped those with daikon radishes just to be able to do it.

The problem is I'd need my own hydroponics or greenhouse to avoid the problems with climate and weather and soil.
 

Jayamos

Farmer
For example, the radish salad requires "French breakfast radishes" which I'd have to grow myself, and even though I've done the roots platter, I had to radically replace one ingredient which felt wrong: Tokyo turnips/hakurei. I swapped those with daikon radishes just to be able to do it.
Daikon is a decent substitute, I think. For radishes… any not too hot radish ought to work. Daikon would be a little wimpy but in the ballpark.
 
Top