My problem with most of the bachelors/bachelorettes is their supposed age. Maru, Sam, Alex, and Abigail all appear to be teens, which would make marrying them a bit difficult in reality. Sebastian, Emily, Shane, Penny, and Haley aren't much older if the lore is correct, but would at least be legal. That leaves Leah, Harvey, and Elliot as the only really age appropriate marriage candidates.
I'm drawn to Leah because she's down to earth and practical, and closer to me irl, lol. If I don't mind the age difference, Sebastian would be my second choice.