alex is fruity
Greenhorn
I find myself split between the same main 12 villagers and honestly, it's a pain. I was wondering who everyone else's favourite is and why!
Curious on who's the most popular...
- Thread starter alex is fruity
- Start date
MogBeoulve
Local Legend
KROBUS!
Lew Zealand
Helper
You forgot the YES option 
alex is fruity
Greenhorn
AddedYou forgot the YES option
HaleyRocks
Farmer
Blunt, straightforward and with a carefully measured dose of (artificial) repulsiveness, just enough to make you earn her, look beyond her outwards appearances, work to know the real her...
I honestly cannot choose any other! Even with only her straightforward demeanor on the table and nothing else, she still would be my first (and only) choice!
I honestly cannot choose any other! Even with only her straightforward demeanor on the table and nothing else, she still would be my first (and only) choice!
Last edited:
FilthyGorilla
Local Legend
I personally usually end up marrying Emily in my saves, she has a really easy schedule and easy gifts. I don’t really have a favourite per se but that’s as close as I could say to one.
Maher
Farmer
If you're an introvert or play one in SDV, It's hard to get better than Maru, who can't wait to get away from any festival (at least through 1.56). She gives 'splodey gifts too! Her cut scenes aren't much, but she more than makes up for it on the day to day. She's also the only one I've encountered who sometimes notices the sprinklers and autofeeders and compliments the level of automation instead of watering irrigated crops and feeding sated animals.
NetworkerC
Planter
As much as I picked ‘Yes’, my own first was Haley (although I had Emily’s 10 first, got the Pendant, crashed into Haley’s 10, and guess where that pendant went!)
I asked King Speed who he would take an interest in, after giving him a brief rundown of each bachelorette. He gave me a
kind of look, as he believes that speed is the only truth in the world (Ah well, you win some, you lose some. 
), but I think, given his spooky thing for the future (this dude can read what traffic’s gonna do, on the C1 Loop, while we’re still on Route 4. It sure keeps me on my toes!), I would imagine that, with how she takes off, in her Heart Events, Motoya would see stable movements in Leah’s future, and marry her.
I absolutely see him getting on well with Sebastian, and his bike, though. I wonder if Seb would ever race that thing? Reminds me of the ‘Chopper of America Bike Club’ in the world of the Midnight Club…
Uh… Where was I going with this? Oh yeah, if the answer isn’t “yes”, then it’s Penny, despite Haley being my first. If you think I’m wrong, please, enlighten me. I asked, and got nowhere.
I asked King Speed who he would take an interest in, after giving him a brief rundown of each bachelorette. He gave me a
kind of look, as he believes that speed is the only truth in the world (Ah well, you win some, you lose some. ), but I think, given his spooky thing for the future (this dude can read what traffic’s gonna do, on the C1 Loop, while we’re still on Route 4. It sure keeps me on my toes!), I would imagine that, with how she takes off, in her Heart Events, Motoya would see stable movements in Leah’s future, and marry her.I absolutely see him getting on well with Sebastian, and his bike, though. I wonder if Seb would ever race that thing? Reminds me of the ‘Chopper of America Bike Club’ in the world of the Midnight Club…
Uh… Where was I going with this? Oh yeah, if the answer isn’t “yes”, then it’s Penny, despite Haley being my first. If you think I’m wrong, please, enlighten me. I asked, and got nowhere.
Last edited:
smellincoffee
Rancher
The bachelors I've wed so far (in different saves) are Penny, Abigail, and Haley. Alex has come very close, though, as have Emily and Leah.
ThePerfectGarden
Farmer
I like them all. Some more, some less, but everyone has an interesting personality.
The bachelors I wed so far were Emily, Sebastian, and Maru. Amongst them, Maru was the nicest partner for my liking. She seemed really interested in me, helped me with useful improvements, she's such a nice down-to-earth person.
But when it comes to love, I would choose Leah and Elliott, they are the ones I feel tuned-in the most. So my next spouse will be Elliott.
Actually, come to think of it, it's Jodi I like the least. At the end of the cutscene with the dinner in their house, when my char says to herself something like "I almost feel part of the family now", my real Me cries out "Ugh, no, I don't want to be part of their family"!
The bachelors I wed so far were Emily, Sebastian, and Maru. Amongst them, Maru was the nicest partner for my liking. She seemed really interested in me, helped me with useful improvements, she's such a nice down-to-earth person.
But when it comes to love, I would choose Leah and Elliott, they are the ones I feel tuned-in the most. So my next spouse will be Elliott.
Actually, come to think of it, it's Jodi I like the least. At the end of the cutscene with the dinner in their house, when my char says to herself something like "I almost feel part of the family now", my real Me cries out "Ugh, no, I don't want to be part of their family"!
Last edited:
i am always live laugh love sebastian. i used to write big essays as to why he's my favorite and maybe i will do that for these forums one day... but for now, his character arc is interesting, his events are lovely, he is incredibly sweet, and i really appreciate him as an adult character, living with his parents but trying to make ends meet on his own, who has yet to find love, which is something way more common than anyone wants to admit. i love how he opens up as a bashful character and he is definitely one of the most thankful marriage candidates when he does "make it"
MintBerryCrunch
Farmhand
I always end up romancing Sam. Even when I try to romance other bachelors.
Alex is boring. Elliot is too wishy-washy. Harvey has no respect for boundaries. Sebastian is okay but I'm not jumping through all kinds of hoops just for you to notice me, dude. And Shane is a straight up asshole to you and I have no appreciation for that and am supremely turned off by that kind of needless hostility.
I feel like there are much better lady options
Alex is boring. Elliot is too wishy-washy. Harvey has no respect for boundaries. Sebastian is okay but I'm not jumping through all kinds of hoops just for you to notice me, dude. And Shane is a straight up asshole to you and I have no appreciation for that and am supremely turned off by that kind of needless hostility.
I feel like there are much better lady options
Brave Little Sapling
Rancher
Elliot and Leah, hands down.
Perhaps I have a subconscious bias for red heads.
I also really like Shane. Harvey has always been very forgettable to me and the other lads seem too young for this ol' gal--Sebastian COULD be an exception because he smokes and rides a motorcycle. Shane is kind of toxic, but his arc is fantastic and how can you hate a man who loves chickens that much?
Haley is definitely my second choice for the ladies. Emily comes in a strong third place though. As mentioned above, the other girls seem too young, and funnily enough Maru is the most forgettable bachelorette to me--the first time I played I didn't even realize she was a character until later in the game.
So maybe I also have a subconscious bias against medical professionals lmao.
I used to dislike Haley, but since playing through a fresh save I see her in a whole new light. I used to be like, "WOW RUDE" when she said, "You'd be cuter with makeup... nevermind," upon meeting her, but now I see it as a closeted lesbian compliment and that makes interacting with her much more enjoyable and hilarious. I just had a flashback of my husband saying, "Is she kissing you?!" after I found her great grandmother's bracelet on the beach.
(Hilariously, in his very first save, Haley was his wife hahaha)
Perhaps I have a subconscious bias for red heads.
I also really like Shane. Harvey has always been very forgettable to me and the other lads seem too young for this ol' gal--Sebastian COULD be an exception because he smokes and rides a motorcycle. Shane is kind of toxic, but his arc is fantastic and how can you hate a man who loves chickens that much?
Haley is definitely my second choice for the ladies. Emily comes in a strong third place though. As mentioned above, the other girls seem too young, and funnily enough Maru is the most forgettable bachelorette to me--the first time I played I didn't even realize she was a character until later in the game.
So maybe I also have a subconscious bias against medical professionals lmao.
I used to dislike Haley, but since playing through a fresh save I see her in a whole new light. I used to be like, "WOW RUDE" when she said, "You'd be cuter with makeup... nevermind," upon meeting her, but now I see it as a closeted lesbian compliment and that makes interacting with her much more enjoyable and hilarious. I just had a flashback of my husband saying, "Is she kissing you?!" after I found her great grandmother's bracelet on the beach.
(Hilariously, in his very first save, Haley was his wife hahaha)
Juju vs Joja
Tiller
I've married Penny and Harvey in previous saves and I love them both! I also really like Emily, although I haven't married her yet. (Yes, my type is "sweethearts").
ArtifactSpot
Guest
lol I think I’d like Elliot much better without the hair drama. He’s vey sweet, a little dramatic, but mostly sweet and a good husband and father. I’ve chosen him several times, But the hair obsession dialogue, even suggesting I’d shave it off in his sleep is a tad too much vanity/drama for me. It got old.
ArtifactSpot
Guest
That is so cool that your husband will play SDV with you! I wish mine would. He says it reminds him of the never ending around tho clock grind of his actual work…I get it. So I settle for Harvey. He’s the best hands down, the most like my irl husband. I say my husband is Harvey with a touch of Sebastian lol. Have you married your irl husband in the game? That’d be my dream come true.I just had a flashback of my husband saying, "Is she kissing you?!" after I found her great grandmother's bracelet on the beach.
In the meantime it’s Harvey every time! 
