When Fishing I need to keep entertained as waiting for a bite is a little on the dull side, so I prefer:
Pirate Profession
2x Dressed Spinner
Deluxe Bait
Luck Buff (Daily Luck, Lucky Lunch, Ginger Ale, etc.)
Fish bite in less than a second and Treasure Chests pop up so frequently that my Inventory fills up quickly. Bring a Big Chest. And because there's no wait for the bite and you get the time freeze when reeling the Fish in (in single player), you can spend a LONG time in-game Fishing and collecting Treasures in a single day.
Because the bite rate is so high, I'd bet this combination will net more Fishing Treasure chests than the Treasure Hunter Bobber, but I'm really using it this way because I don't like the wait before bite.
For the Treasure Totem, I tried it once and what I got wasn't all that great so I haven't made another. Maybe I should make like 25 of them in a tiny
@Ferris Bueller test and see if they're worth it over time.