Who would win in a fight?

BeenASon

BeenASon

Local Legend
Alright let's hear it. Between all the npcs Who would win in a fight? The pairings are Haley vs Penny, Elliot vs Harvey, Shane vs Sam, Lewis vs Willy, Clint vs Gunther, Emily vs Leah, Alex vs Sebastian, Abigail vs Maru, Jodi vs Caroline, Pam vs Marnie, Linus vs Wizard (Wizard can't use magic), Demetrius vs Gus, Morris vs Pierre, Kent vs Marlon, and finally Sandy vs Robin. That should cover everyone except the kids. I can't find anyone for Jas so she's out of the game. Bonus round is Vincent VS Leo. Give your predictions. I tried to keep it fair (That's why it's Marlon vs Kent since there both combat experienced)
 
Haley vs Penny -> Hayley
Elliot vs Harvey -> Elliot (but it would probably be a slap fight)
Shane vs Sam -> Shane
Lewis vs Willy -> Willy (but Lewis might fight dirty)
Clint vs Gunther -> Gunther
Emily vs Leah -> Emily
Alex vs Sebastian -> Alex
Abigail vs Maru -> this is a tough one because Maru is a dark horse so I'm gonna say it's a draw
Jodi vs Caroline -> Caroline
Pam vs Marnie -> Pam
Linus vs Wizard (Wizard can't use magic) -> Linus
Demetrius vs Gus -> Gus
Morris vs Pierre -> Pierre
Kent vs Marlon -> Kent (because he's way younger)
Sandy vs Robin -> Sandy
Vincent vs Leo -> Leo
 
dragonflySky said:
Haley vs Penny -> Hayley
Elliot vs Harvey -> Elliot (but it would probably be a slap fight)
Shane vs Sam -> Shane
Lewis vs Willy -> Willy (but Lewis might fight dirty)
Clint vs Gunther -> Gunther
Emily vs Leah -> Emily
Alex vs Sebastian -> Alex
Abigail vs Maru -> this is a tough one because Maru is a dark horse so I'm gonna say it's a draw
Jodi vs Caroline -> Caroline
Pam vs Marnie -> Pam
Linus vs Wizard (Wizard can't use magic) -> Linus
Demetrius vs Gus -> Gus
Morris vs Pierre -> Pierre
Kent vs Marlon -> Kent (because he's way younger)
Sandy vs Robin -> Sandy
Vincent vs Leo -> Leo
Click to expand...
I can see Haley beating the crap out of Penny by fighting dirty lol. Gouge her eyes out kick her and spit on her.
 
i feel like the junimos could easily kill everyone in pelican town
its like a baby groot situation
 
BeenASon said:
Wizard vs Junimos would be interesting.
Click to expand...
i feel like that would make a perfect wizard quest

“junimos have been invading the town! i need you to bring me x3 solar essence and x5 earth crystals so i can teleport them back to the old town hall.”
 
astnko said:
i feel like that would make a perfect wizard quest

“junimos have been invading the town! i need you to bring me x3 solar essence and x5 earth crystals so i can teleport them back to the old town hall.”
Click to expand...
Yeah! The wizard kickstarts the whole community center it be nice to have more lore and quests to such a important character. Maybe he can teach us spells.
 
BeenASon said:
Pam is out of shape as hell though.
Click to expand...

Never underestimate an alcoholic with anger issues though…
dragonflySky said:
Haley vs Penny -> Hayley
Elliot vs Harvey -> Elliot (but it would probably be a slap fight)
Shane vs Sam -> Shane
Lewis vs Willy -> Willy (but Lewis might fight dirty)
Clint vs Gunther -> Gunther
Emily vs Leah -> Emily
Alex vs Sebastian -> Alex
Abigail vs Maru -> this is a tough one because Maru is a dark horse so I'm gonna say it's a draw
Jodi vs Caroline -> Caroline
Pam vs Marnie -> Pam
Linus vs Wizard (Wizard can't use magic) -> Linus
Demetrius vs Gus -> Gus
Morris vs Pierre -> Pierre
Kent vs Marlon -> Kent (because he's way younger)
Sandy vs Robin -> Sandy
Vincent vs Leo -> Leo
Click to expand...

Maru can electrocute Abigail…
I mean from experience? Maru hands me a bomb at least once a week when we were married and I had to restart the day a lot :/
 
Usepencil said:
Never underestimate an alcoholic with anger issues though…

Maru can electrocute Abigail…
I mean from experience? Maru hands me a bomb at least once a week when we were married and I had to restart the day a lot :/
Click to expand...
Abigail can impale her with quartz. Also abby has some experience in the mines.
 
Haley vs Penny: You would think Haley, but Penny has a lot of built up anger about her mom. Draw, because I don't know if Penny can hold a grudge.
Elliot vs Harvey: Elliot. No explanation needed.
Shane vs Sam: Though Shane is strong, Sam would somehow win using his immense stupidity. Sam is great.
Lewis vs Willy: Willy. Again, I think this one is obvious.
Clint vs Gunther: Some may think Gunther based off of his character, but Clint has strong blacksmith arms. (there's a reason you can't break open geodes yourself)
Emily vs Leah: Leah. She punches her ex if you don't.
Alex vs Sebastian: Alex. He works out all the time.
Abigail vs Maru: I think that I would not want to fight either of them, but Abigail would definitely bring a sword to the fight.
Jodi vs Caroline: This is a hard one, because it's not super obvious. Maybe Caroline, though.
Pam vs Marnie: Pam, if she were drunk. Actually, either way.
Linus vs Wizard: Wizard. Linus doesn't like fighting.
Demetrius vs Gus: Gus. No explanation.
Morris vs Pierre: Pierre beat Morris once already, and he is not afraid to do it again.
Kent vs Marlon: Kent is younger and goes out more often, but Marlon has been sitting around in the adventurer's guild all day and wants to punch someone in the face.
Sandy vs Robin: Robin has strong carpenter arms, but for some reason I think Sandy would win.
Vincent vs Leo: Leo. No explanation.
 
Leo is a tough cookie from living on ginger island tbh. Caroline and Jodi is incredibly unsure since both of them are housewives and are of the same build and height.
Contented-Slime said:
Haley vs Penny: You would think Haley, but Penny has a lot of built up anger about her mom. Draw, because I don't know if Penny can hold a grudge.
Elliot vs Harvey: Elliot. No explanation needed.
Shane vs Sam: Though Shane is strong, Sam would somehow win using his immense stupidity. Sam is great.
Lewis vs Willy: Willy. Again, I think this one is obvious.
Clint vs Gunther: Some may think Gunther based off of his character, but Clint has strong blacksmith arms. (there's a reason you can't break open geodes yourself)
Emily vs Leah: Leah. She punches her ex if you don't.
Alex vs Sebastian: Alex. He works out all the time.
Abigail vs Maru: I think that I would not want to fight either of them, but Abigail would definitely bring a sword to the fight.
Jodi vs Caroline: This is a hard one, because it's not super obvious. Maybe Caroline, though.
Pam vs Marnie: Pam, if she were drunk. Actually, either way.
Linus vs Wizard: Wizard. Linus doesn't like fighting.
Demetrius vs Gus: Gus. No explanation.
Morris vs Pierre: Pierre beat Morris once already, and he is not afraid to do it again.
Kent vs Marlon: Kent is younger and goes out more often, but Marlon has been sitting around in the adventurer's guild all day and wants to punch someone in the face.
Sandy vs Robin: Robin has strong carpenter arms, but for some reason I think Sandy would win.
Vincent vs Leo: Leo. No explanation.
Click to expand...
 
well, elliots pencil does 24-30 damage, and the player has 100 health at the beginning so...
Pencil
but then again harvey has a mallet so
mallet
the mallet does 40-55 damage, but elliots pencil is a dagger, harvey's mallet is a club so attack speed
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

NestorGB
If you were an Stardew Valley NPC, which would you be?
2 3 4
Replies
75
Views
7K
Maher
Arby_notthemeats
Favorite NPCs
2 3
Replies
51
Views
6K
Hollyfox
Hollyfox
  • Poll Poll
Champion of the Valley - Day 1
Replies
16
Views
4K
RennyBenny
RennyBenny
LittleStrawberryLamb
My Boyfriend's opinions on Stardew NPCs
Replies
2
Views
722
LittleStrawberryLamb
LittleStrawberryLamb
Hedhogthe3rd
Who would be the best mayor of Pelican Town?
Replies
16
Views
2K
WorstDecorator
Back
Top