Abigail is the wizards daughter confirmed

[Cuddlebug]

I think we can rule out Evelyn, Jodi and probably Maru. I just don't see Robin and Wizard.

It might be Jas. I'm not sure what the relationship is exactly between Marnie, Jas and Shane. Maybe Jas' mother was Marnie's sister and she met Wizard while visiting Marnie? Maybe she was the kind of young woman who would venture out to the Wizard's Tower just because Marnie warned her to stay away. (She does warn the farmer to stay away in the early days of the game!)
And Jas seems to have natural purple hair.
The picture we get as a secret note could be Marnie's sister with Jas?

That's an interesting thought btw, makes sense to me. Then Marnie had to have two sisters once, when Shane is also her nephew.

 

[Maher]

By the Way is it Maru supposed to be from a different Demetrius marriage?, cause she is brunette but her father has black hair and robin's is Red.

Maru's hair is Auburn (brown with red undertones). It can happen when a dominant gene for black hair does not completely suppress the recessive gene for red hair.

 

[Gamer1234556]

Maybe its just bc Abigail grew up with Pierre, so maybe there was and influence, and its a small town and its not like she went to a big school or lived in Zuzu city and had hundreds, maybe thousands of people influencing her everyday. And I don't know the Wi-fi connection in Pelican Town, so we can't rule out social media as an influence just yet...

Pierre raised her. He housed her, worked to support the household, argued with her, imposed expectations on her, disappointed her, and helped create the personality against which she defines herself. Even their conflict is evidence of intimacy. They know precisely how to aggravate one another because they are family.

I wonder if Rasmodius has done a single thing that can be considered remotely fatherly to Abigail?

Like, I get it. It's just a harmless theory, but you can't help but ask yourself if it's even really all that funny. Something like Joseph from King of the Hill works because it's better thought out as a joke, whereas in here it just feels like a bunch of red herring one-liners would fuel a grand conspiracy without really addressing how underwritten it all is.

 

[Galaxy_Chicken]

Hmmm that old rascal Rasmodius really gets around because Caroline is totally the Wizard's daughter.
But the real question is who's the Wizard's son?

I think Caroline is the wizards secret wife and Abigail is the seceret daughter, there Is a lot of proof to this, as Abigail's hair is naturally purple

 

[Lew Zealand]

I think Caroline is the wizards secret wife and Abigail is the seceret daughter, there Is a lot of proof to this, as Abigail's hair is naturally purple

Except Caroline says this:

Abigail's hair is naturally light chestnut-colored.

 

[Gardening Spirit]

Ahhh the mysteries of Stardew Valley....Concerned Ape is the master of keeping us guessing.

 

[dragonflySky]

I thought Wizard was quite old compared to the others. Like Grandpa's age. What if Pam is Wizard's daughter and Evelyn is her mother? They abandoned her at birth and she was adopted out of town but she returned when she grew up because the birth records were sealed but the location was the only part visible. She drinks because of unresolved abandonment issues.