(900 comments! So close!)Connecting Letters Forum Game! Stardew Valley Theme!

[Narwhal_7]

mini-obelisk

 

[HedgehogIII]

Kitemaster 95

 

[Contented-Slime]

5,000g bundle

 

[zack123]

Elliott's Pencil

 

[HedgehogIII]

Leah

 

[WanderingWendaline]

Hanging shield

 

[zack123]

Dana

(At one point before the game was released, Penny was named "Dana")