Thank you! I'll give it a try xIt looks like the pina colada you can buy from the resort. That isn't something you can make in the vanilla game without mods but maybe that helps?
It's a banana pudding. You have to buy the recipe from the island trader. The vanilla game will never require you to do something that you can only do using a mod.
I took this picture on my cooked items, not from the list you get when you click the oven, rather the one in the menu tab. I brought the pina colada but that didn't do it!The order the dishes appear in doesn't seem to match the collections page, where is this image from? That might help us figure out what it is.
If you bought the pina colada recipe you still have to actually cook the recipe in either of your kitchens or using a cookout kit.I took this picture on my cooked items, not from the list you get when you click the oven, rather the one in the menu tab. I brought the pina colada but that didn't do it!
Where do I buy the recipe? I haven't been able to find the recipe! That's got to be the issue!Did you make the piña colada yet or did you only buy the recipe?
100% no mods on the game- I haven't even got a clue how to add a modThe shadow does not fit with any items in the cooked items list. Are you 100 % sure that you don't have any mod that would add a recipe -- OK, It probably is Piña Colada after all -- but crafting it should not be necessary for perfection.
this is why I'm so confused it doesn't match any of the needed items on the normal unmodded gameI believe you are right!! Didn't see it the first time I looked.The banana pudding is already there, bottom right. The missing one does look like pina colada, as said above, and it's not craftable - you can only buy it from Gus when he's at the island resort bar.