What was your first legendary fish? (Spoilers?)

[REtroGeekery]

Crimsonfish was my first legendary catch. I had no idea why it had a little hat on the fishing bar at first, and apparently I got lucky.

Same here. I was trying to catch something else (I think it was an albacore) and wondered what the little hat meant. It took a few tries but I finally got it with no tackle or bait.

 

[Mr satan]

Wow you are just like me lmao,I didn't know that legendary fish existed, although after unlocking the sewers with 3 in-game days or so I wondered if I can fish in the sewers ,so I did and then I was confused why the fish had a party hat(or whatever the icon is) and then it said you caught one of the legendary fish

 

[3729goldencoconuts]

Mines tge munat carp, it was easy tbh