PS4 Unable to add Pumpkin to Luau Soup

BringsTheSnow

Sodbuster
I am unsure if this is a bug or just something i am misunderstanding in the game. Is there any reason I am unable to add a gold star pumpkin to the Luau Soup?

It is one I grew the previous Fall and had in a chest. I picked it up from the chest just before heading out to the Luau.

Thanks.
 

Attachments

Top