I tried fishing out of the fountain by the playground it was the evening and it was raining. I was able to fish stones and wood out. It seems like I've tried to fish from the fountain before with no luck.
You can get a present, but I personally don’t think it’s worth the time fishing there to get it. Especially when so many other places have better surprises.
I don't know that the rod has anything to do with it, I am using an iridium one and I haven't ever caught anything. I do remember the gift though, it was a decorative trash can.