Rotten Plant variant gift

[BeBop268170]

I've given every loved gift to every villager, and I believe I've given every gift I can possibly give to my wife, Penny, except I CAN'T remember how to make a Rotten Plant (variant). Hopefully somebody knows. Here's a pic of what I'm looking for:

I found a small variety of gifts that show up in the gift log, but aren't even acknowledged as a potential gift in the wiki, though they're all hated gifts:

Pressure Nozzle
Enricher
Void Ghost Pendant
Galaxy Soul
Golden Bobber

Here's a weird error on the Targeted Bait:

 

[BeBop268170]

Nevermind! Solved! Now I've filled out Penny's gift log entirely except for the original Legendary fish/secret note/journal scrap.

I wish I had the patience to give EVERY gift to EVERY villager, and that would be a huge flex for anyone to do, but I believe I'm done gifting now.

 

[NextXander]

Woah, I'm impressed. I respect the commitment to even gift Penny all her hated items, I could never

 

[HaleyRocks]

Excellent work, OP!

I also undertook the exact same quest, which is to gift every villager every possible gift; but it certainly is going to take a long time!

Just for the record, how did you manage to get that rotten plant (variant) as an inventory item, exactly?

 

[BeBop268170]

Just for the record, how did you manage to get that rotten plant (variant) as an inventory item, exactly?

Ah, you leave the Golden Lewis Statue in town and the next day it'll be a Rotten Plant. I would guess a 50% chance of either type.

 

[MogBeoulve]

Is it the same as the one you get from leaving a carved pumpkin outside past the end of fall?

 

[BeBop268170]

Is it the same as the one you get from leaving a carved pumpkin outside past the end of fall?

I left 15 out and got 15 regular Rotten Plants, so I would say no.

I also undertook the exact same quest, which is to gift every villager every possible gift; but it certainly is going to take a long time!

Btw, it was you who gave me the idea to do it.

 

[FilthyGorilla]

Ha, I've been doing the same thing (and similarly decided against filling out everyone's full gift logs for my own sanity), cool to see someone else do it too