Is the wizard Abigail's dad??

[Pangaearocks]

Perhaps. Or she has a problem with sleep-walking into blue paint buckets. Anything is possible!

 

[Lenora Rose]

But Abby has a quote saying she didn't dye her hair in a long time and it just stays that way.

Maybe magical people are born with normal hair color, but it changes at maturity?

Or maybe Caroline was lying. "Hmm, I want my daughter to be normal. Normal people have brownish hair colours. I should say her hair is dyed. Yes, that's it!"

 

[imnvs]

Okay, let me ask a few questions...

Does it matter? Do we investigate our neighbors like this in real life? Do we start telling everyone that our theory (which has no true evidence to back it up but just a lot of coincidence) must be true?

Pierre is an insecure man. Others have strange hair colors. Why the conspiracy theory? Why must we assume the worst of of these folk?

 

[Lenora Rose]

Okay, let me ask a few questions...

Does it matter? Do we investigate our neighbors like this in real life? Do we start telling everyone that our theory (which has no true evidence to back it up but just a lot of coincidence) must be true?

Pierre is an insecure man. Others have strange hair colors. Why the conspiracy theory? Why must we assume the worst of of these folk?

I don't speculate like this about my neighbours but I do about people in stories. Especially since we know authors often leave trails of breadcrumbs for readers/viewers to speculate about. And since ConcernedApe left these breadcrumbs for these characters. he clearly meant there to be speculation.

Characters can feel pretty realish, I know, and we can develop a genuine attachment to them. Nothing wrong with feeling protective over those we care about. But each NPC is in fact a creation with a creator and that creator had intentions in leaving these items for us to pick over.