This Shane's 8 hearts event that needs to be seen, not the 10 hearts event.
Anyway, as ISSsloth mentioned, once this event has been seen, there is a chance when purchasing a chicken that it will be blue. To ensure that you get the wanted colour, when Marnie asks you to choose the coop in which to host the chicken, the colour of the chicken is indicated (brown/white/blue chicken). If this is not the expected colour, just cancel and start the purchase process again until you get the colour you want.