I could see Sam playing, but getting bored with the game quickly.
I could see Shane loving Stardew. He'd be someone who also played a bunch of Harvest Moon games.
I think Emily would play Stardew a little bit, but she's a girl with other hobbies, so I don't think she'd play much.
I don't think Stradew would be Haley's vibe. I think she'd be more of a Sims girl-y.
I could see Maru playing Stardew as a profit player. That kinda player who is more interested in optimization. But even so, I don't think she'd play much Stardew.
Vincent would like the game, but it would be Jas who loves the game. That is... if they are allowed much video game time in their households.