Both are good, but I feel like you get better long term returns from ancient fruit, since it keeps producing from one seed.
Also, I'm partially colorblind and while I know the star fruit is yellow, it tends to look odd to me. I once harvested a stack of what I thought were silver quality starfruit until I harvested an actual silver one and realized the others were gold, lol. I can see the ancient fruit's color and happen to like it. It makes especially pretty wines & jellies now that they're color matched to the fruit. ^_^