What is your favorite skill in SDV?

ArtifactSpot

Guest
Mine is mining. I just can’t get enough mining. Ever. 🤩

Second is foraging both chopping wood and collecting items.

Third, Farming. (More of a Rancher really.)

Fishing is next to last as it can be painfully challenging at times. However trapping (once it no longer requires bait) on the beach farm can be fun. Crab cakes, lobster bisque and sashimi galore!

Last is combat. I secretly enjoy it, but feel bad for killing anything, even pixelated monsters lol. (Especially anyone related to Krobus who is just an adorable underground friend. ☺ )
 

nicodeux

Farmer
I love foraging: cleaning Sindersap Forest from rocks, logs and weeds, collecting wild fruits, mushrooms or flowers... On the farm I am currently playing, it is blackberries season, and I happily collect every single berry in the whole valley, every day, before doing any other chore on the farm.

Second is farming at the beginning of a farm, fishing third.
But once I got the production on the farm under control and did most of the achievements, bundles and quests related to farming, I usually loose interest in this skill (in year 2, most of the time). Then, fishing becomes more interesting (because, it is less challenging also) and I like spending time fishing, just for fun.

Mining and combat are only interesting when things explode: bombs and napalm ring, I need thee!
 

ArtifactSpot

Guest
I love foraging: cleaning Sindersap Forest from rocks, logs and weeds, collecting wild fruits, mushrooms or flowers... On the farm I am currently playing, it is blackberries season, and I happily collect every single berry in the whole valley, every day, before doing any other chore on the farm.

Second is farming at the beginning of a farm, fishing third.
But once I got the production on the farm under control and did most of the achievements, bundles and quests related to farming, I usually loose interest in this skill (in year 2, most of the time). Then, fishing becomes more interesting (because, it is less challenging also) and I like spending time fishing, just for fun.

Mining and combat are only interesting when things explode: bombs and napalm ring, I need thee!
I love berry seasons! The blackberry is coolest. Maybe cause of the fall look? And they glow in the dark a bit lol.

Napalm is the best ring by far! It really helps find stairs and shafts more easily too in the mines, without needing the make a bunch of bombs. It’s so hard to get though until later game.
 

ArtifactSpot

Guest
Fighting makes me very happy. Anything else...... =Boredom
lol! So you hang out in the mines more than the rest of SDV too! I love the loot they leave behind, especially with the burglar ring. On a lucky day you can really clean up some great finds. ☺

I’ve actually done a no farming, mostly mining only farm before with a touch of foraging too for free food and needed wood.

Which mine is your favorite?
I like the volcano and dangerous mines best. I have that shrine always turned on once I get it.[spoiler\]
 
Last edited by a moderator:

DragonGwen

Farmer
lol! So you hang out in the mines more than the rest of SDV too! I love the loot they leave behind, especially with the burglar ring. On a lucky day you can really clean up some great finds. ☺

I’ve actually done a no farming, mostly mining only farm before with a touch of foraging too for free food and needed wood.
Look at my about page and you'll see how good I am....... I do really like the skull caverns too (I have two pairs of mermaid boots that's how often I do the Volcano)
 

Lew Zealand

Helper
I'm not sure so I'll just list them and see how I feel.

Mining. Not really a favorite as I super don't like needing to dodge or fight the boingy things or the bitey things or the chasey things or the squishy jumping things or the floaty things or the flappy things. But with one of the soundtracks (A Flicker in the Deep) and a monster-free level, it's fleeting bliss.

Combat. Um. So it seems I outed myself above there. Not my favorite by a long shot.

Farming. Well, you'd think I read Grandpa's letter but I'm really not one for comprehension. I like to feel, not analyze. So yeah, whoda thunk I'd end up with this scraggly bit of ground covered in a patchy forest, eh? And then some old dude tries to convince me there's like a farm in the area but totally never tells me where it is. Sad, but senility creeps up on all of us eventually. So yeah. Farming. When I find it, I'll let you know.

Fishing. Initially this seemed like the local hazing ritual as it was clearly impossible and you just know those fish were given sugar or Red Bull when you start. But I eventually got the hang of it. Overbait your hook, lean back on tree trunk, slide down to nestle between roots, prop pole on knees, let line out slowly and let the warm cozy afternoon take its course. Do not fight Nature, she is your friend.

Foraging. At first blush this may seem like a good way to ruin a perfectly nice walk, but really this is your community service. All these nice people invite you into their town, give you a run-down house and a meadow that's trying it's best to become a forest if you just back off and don't meddle. The least you can do is deprive them of their freely created forage. Find Linus' blackberry basket but forage the snot out of those bushes so he's left with the stragglers. Which you left in Cindersap because they're too far away. From Linus, too. Forage up all those Daffodils and Dandelions to give to Caroline and Harvey and Penny and Emily and Haley. As if they never go outside.

Ever.

And say, read a book right next to a Dandelion or take pictures right next to a Daffodil.

Forage up those Mushrooms and Horseradishes to give to Leah when she specifically tells you she likes to grab them for salads. Give her a few and now she owes likes you where she was self-sufficient before.

Yeah. Foraging is the most satisfying as I'm just walkin' here and those things are just gonna get dirtier and dirtier if I leave them sitting out there for the rest of the week. The real skill I learned in college was foraging for free food, and then I find this rural college simulator game where you get to snerfle out all the hidden free goodies which come back week after week.

Stay in school kids, it really does prepare you for the real world.
 
Last edited:
Love what you said about foraging @Lew Zealand and @nicodeux!

Forgaing is my favourite skill along with farming. I really enjoy the changing of the seasons and waiting for each crop to be ready to harvest or finding new forage. I'm playing with no mods on my current farm so I can play the game at a slower pace without having any quick mod shortcuts to anything. It's so different to my first Year 6 farm with like 30 mods.

I can see fighting and mining is popular but I just can't get into it although it does get a bit more enjoyable deeper into the mines when you get better loot for your efforts.

Neutral on fishing but find it relaxing standing there next to the ocean with the sound of the waves.
 

FilthyGorilla

Local Legend
I love me some mining and combat, people scoff at stardew “combat” but I’m a simple person at heart and love my simple things, regardless of how easy it is. There is a very good skill roof.

next would be farming I guess, I love decking out my farm with lots of buildings. Fishing is fun for the treasure and good to unwind and foraging feels like far too much of a support skill to be enjoyed on its own.
 
Foraging and fishing are my favorites because they give the best perks for leveling up. Once you get botanist, everything you pick up off the ground is iridium quality! Even truffles, bat fruit, seashells, even berries from the bushes. Three iridium blackberries per bush! And every level up in fishing makes your catch bar bigger, you eventually get bait, and tackle. Cork bobbers and trap bobbers are great!
 

Infirain

Cowpoke
Mining with explosive ammo is satisfying, so probably that.
But fishing is also enjoyable! Looking at your bar increase with each level and your new tackle helping you with the catch is just amazing
 

farmer-ys

Cowpoke
Gotta say I love farming the most, followed by mining. If I had to pick two things to be doing it would be those two, just going around the farm in the morning to keep everything going and then off to the mines to loot
 

Anto

Farmhand
Mine are fishing and mining, I just love the feeling of breaking rocks, getting minerals and gems, finding ladders. (I used to love eliminating enemys but the skull cavern kinda ruined it) And love spending my day at the beach fishing, no stress just relaxing. The stress come afterwords when you need a specific fish and the game suddenly decides to make it the rarest one.
 
Two years ago I would have said foraging because it's fail-proof, and while I still love foraging for the simplicity and to see how much time it takes me to run across the entire valley in a day (usually out of desperation to find all 12 leeks for George), fishing has taken the number one spot after completing my first solo-playthrough.

Fish are a great income source early on while waiting for your farm to develop--plus, it makes papa Willie happy--meals that require some type of fish are almost OP (looking at you, Spicy Eel and Lucky Lunch) because most of them give additional buffs, and once you get trapper bobbers + max skill level, it's practically effortless to devastate the local waterways and complete your fish collection.

I do still enjoy farming, mining, and combat, but of those three, I prefer mining because you can never ever have too much stone or coal, and it's delightfully satisfying flying through Skull Cavern once you become proficient; though that's also dependent on your combat capabilites unless you just carpet bomb every floor, which let's be real, I absolutely do.

I'm very excited to see how the skill levels are expanded in 1.6!
 

nicodeux

Farmer
how much time it takes me to run across the entire valley in a day (usually out of desperation to find all 12 leeks for George)every floor, which let's be real, I absolutely do.
Though it's fun to roam in the valley to find forage items, leeks are not the most easy to find (at least, that's what I observed. To be sure to get them in due time, I usually plant a good number of Spring Wild Seeds in the greenhouse during winter (or Ginger Island if already available), so I have (close to) 12 leeks ready to be harvested by the beginning of Spring of year 2, thus I can complete the quest (almost) as soon it is available.

I'm very excited to see how the skill levels are expanded in 1.6!
Me too, !
 
Though it's fun to roam in the valley to find forage items, leeks are not the most easy to find (at least, that's what I observed. To be sure to get them in due time, I usually plant a good number of Spring Wild Seeds in the greenhouse during winter (or Ginger Island if already available), so I have (close to) 12 leeks ready to be harvested by the beginning of Spring of year 2, thus I can complete the quest (almost) as soon it is available.
I absolutely suck at saving my forageables to make any kind of Wild Seeds, but that's a brilliant idea! Definitely going to try to rely on the Wild Seeds a bit more in my next playthrough to save me the heartache of finding only 11/12 leeks for George by the end of the quest. 😅
 
Top