Windows Willy Doesn't Give Calico Eggs if not at festival

[susb8383]

I got to the Desert Festival on day 2 quickly before it opened and fulfilled Willy's fishing quest. Then I took the bus home and met Willy as he was walking to the bus. I talked to him and he gave me the correct dialog "Congrats, here are your eggs" basically, but the number of calico eggs I was carrying never increased.

V1.6.15 build 24356
On a PC
English
Win 11